Skip to main content

G-22 (Buildings) / G-23 (Products) Data quality

Aspect G-22 (Buildings) / G-23 (Products) Data quality

Description
Generally speaking, the data quality in LCA refers to the relevance of generic or specific LCA data in accordance with the goal and scope of the study. Depending on the background data sources (literature, industry data), and the boundaries and context of the study (e.g. for which purposes or countries are the data being used?), the data quality can be very different within one study. Although data may be of good quality for context Y, this will not necessarily be the case for context Z, as the requirements (e.g. geographical representativeness) may be different. The practitioner should keep in mind that data quality is always a relative concept. In order to point out this aspect as transparently as possible, the quality of the data has to be justified in the context of its use. How should the quality of the LCA data be described, and can the practitioner ensure that data of a specific quality are needed and produced?
Related study
objective
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Related study
phase
☐
Goal and scope definition
☒
Inventory analysis (LCI)
☐
Impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
Interpretation
☐
Reporting
Relevant for
New buildings

Existing buildings

Building products

Screening LCA

Simplified LCA

Complete LCA

Provisions
The data quality of LCA studies should at least meet the requirements of EN 15978 and EN 15804, and the documentation, nomenclature, method and review should be implemented accordingly.

Rules from
EN 15978
10.3 Data quality
Different criteria are given in EN 15978, e.g. technological, geographical and temporal coverage (the data should be not older than 10 years). The data should be based on a one-year average (if relevant); check the plausibility and the significance of the data in the final result.

EN 15804
6.3.7 Data quality requirements

ILCD Handbook
6.8 Representativeness and appropriateness of LCI data provisions
6.8.2 Technological representativeness
6.8.3 Geographical representativeness
6.8.4 Time-related representativeness

Annex A: Data quality concept and approach
12.1 Introduction and overview
In the ILCD Handbook, two approaches are defined – 1) data quality in a stricter sense; and 2) the data quality documentation and review:
1) ILCD overall data quality indicators include: technological, geographical, time-related representativeness, completeness, precision/uncertainty, methodological appropriateness and consistency.
2) Data quality documentation aspects cover: documentation, review, nomenclature (e.g. same list of elementary flows)
12.2 Data quality aspects
The ILCD Handbook defines ‘accuracy’ as a term covering all the related data quality aspects, such as:
“Representativeness (technological, geographical, time-related)
Completeness
Methodological appropriateness and consistency”
The ILCD Handbook also provides rules for not mixing the data quality aspects (falling under the term ‘accuracy’) with the other concept of ‘precision’ (or ‘uncertainty’). A graphical illustration (see Figure 11) illustrates this point.


Guidance
In current practice it is usually not possible to choose datasets for quality reasons, but for availability in the construction sector. The practitioner should keep in mind that data quality is crucial for the LCA study. The most appropriate data should be chosen (in terms of representativeness and consistency) as far as possible. Documentation of the used datasets and the quality level is needed as far as possible.
The ILCD Handbook provides some recommendations on data quality, depending on the relative significance of the data in the final results. A graphical illustration (see Figure 12) illustrates this point.

Related study objective: comparative assertion, Related study objective: stand-alone LCA, Related study phase: Inventory analysis (LCI), Study type: Complete LCA, Study type: Screening LCA, Study type: Simplified LCA