Skip to main content

B-11 (Buildings) / B-06 (Products) Definition of the service life of a building product

Aspect B-11 (Buildings) / B-06 (Products) Definition of the service life of a building product

Description
The lifespan, or service life, of building components and elements is usually defined as the period of time during which their performance meets or exceeds initial requirements. More detailed definitions can be found in reference work (e.g. the ISO 15686 series [ISO 15686] and [Guidance Paper F 2004] concerning the Construction Products Directive). Service life depends on many parameters, and is one subject of the ISO 15686 series.
Related
study objective
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Related
study phase
☒
goal and scope definition
☐
inventory analysis (LCI)
☐
impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
interpretation
☐
reporting
Relevant for
new buildings

existing buildings

construction products

screening LCA

simplified LCA

complete LCA

Provisions
The service life of a product or building component has an influence on several aspects of the use stage of building LCA:

  • It should be taken into account for calculation of the frequency of replacement when the service life of the component is lower than the reference study period (refer to the aspect ‘Replacement frequency: whole number replacement cycles’ for further detail).
  • It should be provided with a maintenance scenario (and valid only under the conditions described with this scenario), as required by EN 15804 (annex A).
  • The performance of products and components usually declines gradually. Whenever possible, the loss of performance should be taken into account if it has an influence on other aspects of the use stage (e.g. modification of the performance of heating and cooling systems, insulation, etc. may have an influence on energy consumption).

The service life of a product or component is influenced by many parameters, notably the indoor and outdoor environments, maintenance level, design of the product, etc. (see ISO 15868-8 for further information). When providing information related to service life for an EPD, ISO 15804 requires that the intended use and in-use conditions of the product or system be specified and documented (EN 15804, Annex A).

When developing LCA at the building scale on the basis of several EPDs, it should be verified that the declared service lives and in-use conditions are compatible with the specifics of the building (notably its location and maintenance scenarios).

Only end of life related to loss of performance should be taken into account in the base-case scenario. End of life related to obsolescence (e.g. replacement of the product system by a newly developed or more efficient one before the end of life) may, however, be assessed in a complementary assessment. For more information on obsolescence please refer to ISO 15686-1 (Chapter 7).


Rules from
EN 15978 7.4.4.1 General

8.3 Time related characteristics

8.6.3 Scenarios for maintenance, repair, replacement

EN 15804 6.3.3. Reference service life

7.3.3.1 B1–B5 use stage related to the building fabric

Annex A


Guidance
The RSL could be based on empirical, probabilistic or statistical data, but should always take into account the intended use (description of use) as described in ISO 15686-1, -2, -7 and -8 [EN 15804, Annex A]. RSL should be determined on the basis of:

  • individual EPDs (cradle to gate with corresponding option, or cradle to grave);
  • client requirements and current practices;
  • product and component manufacturers’ information;
  • existing applicable standards such as ISO 15686-1, -2, -7 and -8;
  • the conventional service life in a national context or within an LCA software package for buildings.

It is expected that some service life data may be missing for the assessment at the building scale. In this case, several additional sources may be used to determine the service life of the product or system:

  • publicly available or commercial databases, including in some cases those related to whole-life costing;
  • research group publications and initiatives, such as the joint CIB/RILEM technical committee (CIB W080/RILEM TC 175-SLM);
  • scientific publications, e.g. from the DBMC conferences (International

    B-12 (Buildings) / B-07 (Products) Replacement frequency

    Aspect B-12 (Buildings) / B-07 (Products) Replacement frequency

    Description
    The frequency of replacement is related to the reference study period and the reference service life of the component to be replaced. The ratio between them could lead to a partial number of replacements (e.g. where the reference study period is 30 years but the reference service life for a component is 20 years). Should replacement cycles be calculated as ‘whole-number/full number’ of replacements, or does it make sense to calculate ‘proportionate/partial’ cycles of replacement?
    Related
    study objective
    ☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
    Related
    study phase
    ☒
    goal and scope definition
    ☐
    inventory analysis (LCI)
    ☐
    impact assessment (LCIA)
    ☐
    interpretation
    ☐
    reporting
    Relevant for
    new buildings

    existing buildings

    construction products

    screening LCA

    simplified LCA

    complete LCA

    Provisions
    As the baseline scenario, replacement cycles have to be calculated in whole numbers, according to EN 15978 and EN 15804 (examples are given there). Only whole numbers of replacements are allowed (no partial replacements). The number of replacements is related to the reference study period and the reference service life of the component to replace. The number of replacements must be rounded up unless justified. In order to show the effect of improved durability, a scenario with partial replacement cycles can be made. This scenario has to be documented and justified, and a sensitivity analysis conducted by comparison with the baseline scenario.

    Rules from
    EN 15978 8.6.4 Scenarios for refurbishment – Module B5

    9.3.3 Replaceable components and number of replacements

    EN 15804 6.3.4.4.2 B1–B5 Use stage information modules related to the building fabric: – B4 Replacement
    ILCD 6.10.3 Considered alternatives, the functional unit, and assumptions

    Provisions: 6.10 Comparisons between systems


    Guidance
    Partial replacement numbers should be avoided. Replacement numbers should be rounded up, unless justified as described below:
    The last replacement of components may be skipped, provided:
    – the component is not essential to security, health or comfort;
    – the absence of replacement is based on actual practice;
    – the final replacement occurs during the last 10% of the study period;
    – a specific maintenance scenario is developed in this case.
    This guidance needs to be applied homogeneously in comparisons. For example, for a study period of 50 years, in the case of an internal paint with a 15-year reference service life the last replacement could be ignored (i.e. two replacements rather than three).

    B-08 Modelling of energy use

    Aspect B-08 Modelling of energy use

    Description
    Is B6 relevant at a product level? How should the operational energy use be modelled?
    Related
    study objective
    ☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
    Related
    study phase
    ☒
    goal and scope definition
    ☐
    inventory analysis (LCI)
    ☐
    impact assessment (LCIA)
    ☐
    interpretation
    ☐
    reporting
    Relevant for
    new buildings

    existing buildings

    construction products

    screening LCA

    simplified LCA

    complete LCA

    Provisions
    Energy used by products during the use stage should be assessed in terms of importance. For a product, a scenario may be defined if the product is relevant for the energy supply of a building. However, the actual operational energy use can only be given for a building; data for this module for products are always based on a specific scenario, and do not necessarily apply to other situations.

    Rules from
    EN 15804 6.2.5 B6–B7, use stage, information modules related to the operation of the building

    Guidance
    The regulated energy use (the energy use covered by national building regulations in Member States) of building-integrated technical systems is determined by the design of the building and the use of the building. Regulated energy use reported in Module B6 would normally be provided at a building level through modelling with the relevant national system derived from the Energy Performance in Buildings Directive.

    At a product level, it is not possible to model the relevant regulated operational energy use related to the product, because it is dependent on all the other parts of the building, although the product could be included within a ‘model’ building and a building assessment undertaken.

    If a product requires non-regulated energy to use it – for example a blind that requires electricity for operation, or an intelligently glazed panel that requires electricity to switch to clear from opaque, or a grey water system that requires energy for pumping – then this energy use should also be modelled in Module B6. This would need to be based on a scenario for use, such as the number of operations per day. The results of Module B6 should be separated from the other modules. Additional data to support the development of relevant scenarios on building level should be provided if relevant in the product LCA study, even if the use stage modules are not assessed at the product level.

    B-09 Modelling of water use

    Aspect B-09 Modelling of water use

    Description
    Is B7 relevant at a product level? How should the operational water use be modelled?
    Related
    study objective
    ☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
    Related
    study phase
    ☒
    goal and scope definition
    ☐
    inventory analysis (LCI)
    ☐
    impact assessment (LCIA)
    ☐
    interpretation
    ☐
    reporting
    Relevant for
    new buildings

    existing buildings

    construction products

    screening LCA

    simplified LCA

    complete LCA

    Provisions
    In general, the user has to decide whether this aspect is important for the product; the consideration of operational water use in Module B7 is necessary only for complete LCA studies.

    Rules from
    EN 15804 6.3.4.4.3 B6–B7 use stage information modules related to the operation of the building

    Guidance
    The regulated water use of building-integrated technical systems is determined by the design and use of the building. Attention should be paid to avoid double counting between the product and the building scale.

    B-28 (Buildings) / B-10 (Products) Accounting of different types of waste water treatment

    Aspect B-28 (Buildings) / B-10 (Products) Accounting of different types of waste water treatment

    Description
    The environmental impacts are different for the various methods of waste water treatment. The system boundaries for waste water treatment considered within the studies (e.g. public sewage system, on-site treated water) and the classification of waste water treatment need to be consistent.
    Related
    study objective
    ☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
    Related
    study phase
    ☒
    goal and scope definition
    ☐
    inventory analysis (LCI)
    ☐
    impact assessment (LCIA)
    ☐
    interpretation
    ☐
    reporting
    Relevant for
    new buildings

    existing buildings

    construction products

    screening LCA

    simplified LCA

    complete LCA

    Provisions
    This aspect should be modelled only when it is a special focus of the study, or for a complete LCA, unless it is believed to be a dominant contributor to the environmental impacts of the assessed system. In this case, the real situation should be modelled, and alternative scenarios can be developed as sensitivity analyses. These scenarios should be documented as transparently as possible.

    Rules from
    EN 15978 8.6.6 Scenarios for operational water use (Module B7)
    According to EN 15978, For building studies, water use (treatment and supply) and waste water treatment should be considered in Module B7. Energy to heat or cool water used would be included in Module B6.
    EN 15804 6.3.4.4.3 B6–B7 use stage information modules related to the operation of the building:
    According to EN 15804, Module B7 deals with operational water use within the building. As such, in product LCA it would be included only where building integrated technical system products have an operational water demand. Additionally, the impacts of waste water treatment should be considered for the water used.
    Product-related water use and waste water treatment during the extraction or manufacturing process should be included in Modules A1–A3, during construction in Module A5 and from maintenance (e.g. cleaning) in Module B2.

    Guidance
    In general, waste water treatment as part of material production is included in background datasets. The use of generic waste water treatment data from background databases may ease the assessment of this aspect, and should typically be sufficient for construction-related LCA studies (except for studies that include processes with significant pollution of waste water, such as varnishing processes with high waste water runoff). Regarding the way to treat wastewater in an improved model e.g. for a complete LCA, all types of wastewater treatment should be considered: 1) on-site treatment (different technologies); 2) public sewage system (combined sewer system, both rain and grey/blackwater or separate sewer system); 3) combined technologies (e.g. one technology for on-site treatment and one technology for the public sewage system). Specific LCA data representative of each technology should be used (if available).

    B-31 (Buildings) / B-11 (Products) Distinction between Modules B2, B3, B4 and B5

    Aspect B-31 (Buildings) / B-11 (Products) Distinction between Modules B2, B3, B4 and B5

    Description
    Modules B2 to B5 cover the impacts related to the service life of building and building parts, whether it is a light modification, such as a small maintenance operation or an important retrofit (rehabilitation). It is sometimes difficult to determine which module a specific operation should be attributed to. The present aspect proposes a common definition of these modules, plus recommendations on how to use them at the product and building scale.
    Related
    study objective
    ☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
    Related
    study phase
    ☒
    goal and scope definition
    ☐
    inventory analysis (LCI)
    ☐
    impact assessment (LCIA)
    ☐
    interpretation
    ☐
    reporting
    Relevant for
    new buildings

    existing buildings

    construction products

    screening LCA

    simplified LCA

    complete LCA

    Provisions
    Standards EN 15804 and EN 15978 provide definitions and examples of aspects B2 to B5. The LCA practitioner should refer to these standards.

    B2 – Maintenance encompasses all actions related to maintaining a product or building part – i.e. replacement or reparation of a used, damaged or worn part of the product (a part, but not the entire functional unit) in a state in which it can perform its functions [EN 15978]. According to EN 15978, this applies to planned actions, and should include:

    • preventive and regular maintenance operations;
    • cleaning operations.

    Maintenance actions are part of the ‘intended use’ definition that should be provided with a product’s reference service life (see EN 15804, annex A and 7.3.3.2 Reference service life). The reference service life (RSL) is valid under a specific set of conditions, notably the in-use environment (e.g. UV, heat, humidity, etc.), and proper implementation and maintenance that comply with the producer’s recommendations and with state-of-the-art practices. The RSL should be used to calculate the number of replacements. See the aspects: ‘Definition of the service life of a building product’ and ‘replacement frequency’ for additional information.

    B3 – Repair encompasses all actions related to returning a product or building part to an acceptable condition in which it can perform its required functional and technical performances [EN 15804], including:

    • corrective, responsive or reactive treatment of a construction product;
    • replacement of a broken component or part because of damage (replacement of a whole element should be assigned to replacement).

    The example given in EN 15978 and EN 15804 is a window with a broken pane.

    –> Although the distinction between the maintenance and repair modules is not straightforward, the example given for repair falls outside the scope of the intended use that defines reference service life.

    B4 – Replacement covers the replacement of a whole construction element [EN 15804], including the production and installation of a new (and identical) construction element. Examples given in EN 15978 include replacement of a partition wall, and replacement of a boiler or heating system.

    –> The replacement module is distinguished from the maintenance and repair modules by the fact that a complete component or part is replaced (maintenance include the replacement of subcomponents, and repair the replacement of damaged parts). Although this ultimately depends on the breakdown of the building into subcomponents, it seems reasonable to understand it as the replacement of a complete functional unit such as defined in the EPD.

    B5 – Refurbishment covers concerted programmes of maintenance, repair and/or replacement activity across a significant part or whole section of the building [EN 15804]. Examples provided include: ‘a major change of the internal layout (partitioning)’, a ‘change of the technical system related to heating’ and ‘modification for the purpose of a […] change of use’ [EN 15978].

    –> The refurbishment module addresses important modifications that would impact on several building components, and modify building performances and/or functions.

    All these aspects are related to the notions of durability and service life planning, as described in the ISO 15686 series. Relations between the type of operations and performance of a given product or building part could be represented as follows:

    Figure 18: Example of performance over time relation depending on operations [EN 15804]

    This figure is shown only for explanation purpose, and many other cases are possible, such as:

    • performance stability over the reference study period;
    • overall decrease of performance despite maintenance operations;
    • failure at implementation.

    Furthermore, “service life planning can only address foreseeable changes. Since service life planning is concerned with foreseeable risks, it is not applicable to the estimation of obsolescence […] or to defective performance resulting from unforeseeable events or processes” [ISO 15686-1, part B.8.2.].

    In the case of sound statistical feedback on the replacement rate of a specific product for a given country or region, it is unlikely that a clear distinction between the causes of replacement could be easily made. In that specific case, replacement causes would naturally encompass all cases: i.e. premature failure, failure due to foreseeable ageing (i.e. RSL) and obsolescence. The figure below presents a hypothetical distribution of replacement rate according to the main causes of replacement (including building deconstruction).

    Figure 19: Replacement rate [EN15804]

     


    Rules from
    EN 15978 7.4.4.1 General

    8.6.3 Scenarios for maintenance, repair, replacement

    EN 15804 6.3.3. Reference service life

    6.3.4.4.2 – B4 Replacement

    Annex A


    Guidance
    As the distinction between Modules B2 to B5 is not straightforward, it is recommended that the following principles be applied when developing product and building LCA. These principles are based solely on the distinction between the causes of end of life:

    –> For end of life related to performance decrease over time (e.g. aging, decay, degradations, etc.):

    • causes related to foreseeable events (i.e. related to reference service life) in a defined set of conditions lead to maintenance and replacement scenarios;
    • causes related to unforeseeable events lead to repair scenarios.

    –> For end of life related to modification of expectations regarding the building’s performance level or functionalities (e.g. obsolescence, such as modification of activities inside the building, modification of regulation, etc.):

    • causes lead to refurbishment scenarios.

    B2 – Maintenance:

    For product LCA, this module should cover all operations necessary to maintain the performance of products, or to return them to their original level, including scheduled replacement of parts and subcomponents. Examples include: scheduled replacement of boiler parts; scheduled replacement of light bulbs from luminaires; repainting of a wall, door or window frame; replacement of small elements of roofing, such as tiles (e.g. a certain number of tile per 10 years per square metre), etc.

    For building LCA, maintenance should take into account maintenance modules as provided within EPD, as well as additional information if needed (e.g. current or state-of-the-art practices, recommendations, etc.).

    –> Maintenance should be understood as the set of operations performed under normal conditions. This applies in a given context (e.g. maintenance of a product could change, depending on the climate). Product modification and operations caused by accidents, improper installation or handling, unforeseeable events (such as flood), etc. should be covered by the repair module (see below).

    –> Maintenance scenarios at the building scale should be consistent with the building’s physical structure: maintenance of a given component should take into account the influence of neighbouring components (e.g. accessibility).

    B3 – Repair:

    For product LCA, the repair module should not be included in the baseline scenario.

    For building LCA, the repair module should not be included in the baseline scenario. The repair module may cover all operations related to product modification outside the scope of the maintenance module – that is, outside the scope of normal conditions, including improper use of a product, unforeseeable events such as flood or vandalism, etc.

    –> For existing buildings, repair scenarios could be based on the history of the building (i.e. examples based on previous reparation);

    –> For new buildings, repair scenarios could be used to assess the environmental impacts of a specific risk (e.g. the impact of reparation due to flood, the impact of improper installation that causes damage, etc.).

    B4 – Replacement:

    Replacement is necessarily related to the reference service life. Replacement occurs at the end of life of a product: that is, when it does not meet its initial performance requirements (modification of the requirements after product installation should be considered as obsolescence, and be covered by a specific scenario: see below). The number of replacements is further described in the aspect ‘Replacement frequency’.

    –> It is recommended that replacement caused by events that are outside the scope of condition defined by the reference service life be treated as repair.

    For product LCA, replacement covers the replacement of the whole functional unit by a new one after RSL. The boundaries of replacement include [EN 15978]:

    • production of the replaced component and ancillary products;
    • transportation of the replaced component and ancillary products, including production impacts and aspects of any losses of materials during transportation;
    • the process of replacing the components and ancillary products;
    • waste management of the removed component and of ancillary products;
    • the end-of-life stage of the removed component and of ancillary products.

    Most of these may be similar to other modules for cradle-to-grave product LCA, for instance:

    • The transport scenario of the new component may be similar to A4 – Transport.
    • The replacement process may be similar to C1 – Deconstruction.

    –> If no differences arises from a comparison between a replacement scenario and an installation scenario (including related production, transport, end of life, etc.) then a replacement scenario is not necessary. In any case, it should be clearly stated whether or not the assumptions regarding B4 modules are similar to those used for other modules (e.g. the replacement process is different from the initial implementation because of the building structure, etc.).

    For building LCA, replacement should include:

    • replacement modules as described in cradle-to-grave EPDs (or cradle-to-gate EPD with corresponding option);
    • additional LCA data to cover components without EPD.

    –> Replacement scenarios at the building scale should be consistent with the building physical structure. Replacement of a given component should take into account the influence of neighbouring components (e.g. accessibility, possible replacement of other components, etc.).

    B5 – Refurbishment

    For product LCA, no refurbishment module need be included in the baseline scenario, as this is highly dependent on information at the product scale.

    For building LCA, the refurbishment module should not be included in the baseline scenario if the building service life is equivalent to the reference study period. Additional refurbishment scenarios may be developed. For example:

    • to assess the modification of building functions (e.g. switching from a commercial building to habitation);
    • to assess the effect of an expected regulation that would affect the buildings.

    –> A refurbishment (or deconstruction/new construction) scenario should be developed if the service life of the building is less than the reference study period.

    It is recommended that a refurbishment scenario be developed when long reference study periods (>100 years) are being considered, as modification of the building use is expected over such a period of time. Refurbishment scenarios could also be developed if the reference study period is longer than the reference service life of the load-bearing components and structural elements.

    Additional recommendations:

    The progressive loss of performance of some components will have an impact on the overall performance of the building (e.g. loss of performance of insulation may lead to an increase of energy demand for heating). If sufficient data are available, these aspects should be addressed using a sensitivity analysis.

    According to NEN 15804 (Annex A), Reference service life “could be based on empirical, probabilistic or statistical data and shall always taking into account the intended use (description of use) as described in ISO 15686-1, -2, -7 and -8” [EN 15804, Annex A].