Skip to main content

Tag: Study type: Complete LCA

G-25 Choice of LCI/LCIA-datasets for complete LCA

Aspect G-25 Choice of LCI/LCIA datasets for complete LCA

Description
Different LCI/LCIA data are needed to assess the environmental impacts of buildings. They make it possible to quantify the different impacts related to the building products and equipment, the construction site, the operational energy and water uses, and the deconstruction of the building. Depending on the study type (screening, simplified or complete), different LCI/LCIA data can be used in practice, depending on their availabilities at the European level, but also in a national context (average, generic or specific LCI/LCIA data for building materials, products and processes). How can this be addressed for complete LCA?
Related
Study Goal
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Related
Study Phase
☐
Goal and scope definition
☒
Life cycle inventory analysis (LCI)
☐
Life cycle impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
Interpretation
☐
Reporting
Relevant for
New buildings

Existing buildings

Construction products

Screening LCA

Simplified LCA

Complete LCA

Provisions
The LCA practitioner or the user of dedicated building LCA tools should use adapted data for description of the building components in complete LCA. In contrast with simplified LCA, the data should reflect the building element, product or material more closely. They can represent a full building component (e.g. 1 m2 concrete block wall insulated with wood wool), or a building product (e.g. 1 m2 of rockwool) or a building material (1 m3 of ready-mixed concrete), depending on the need of the practitioner and the stage of the building project. Provisions for the choice of data to use for complete LCA for the construction site, the operational energy and water uses, and the deconstruction activities are described in the corresponding aspects. LCA data for the building products cited above should correspond to specific industry data (e.g. EPD data) provided by the building manufacturers at the European level, or also in the national context; generic or average LCA data (refer to the provisions for simplified LCA) should be used if specific data (e.g. EPD) are currently missing for some building products or technical equipment. Cut-off rules and impact categories may be considered according to the ILCD Handbook if the goal of the study is to assess indicators and data beyond the EN 15804 cut-off and impact category. The practitioner is likely to deviate from the above provision and use instead generic or average datasets providing a high level of detail in terms of the cut-off and impact categories to be calculated.

Rules from
EN 15978 9.4 Type of data for the assessment
The type of LCA data for the assessment referred in EN 15978 to the CEN/TR 15941. The choice of the data will depend on several aspects including stage of the building project, intended use/scope etc. According to EN 15978 the data (either bill of quantities, building description of components or the LCA data) may be given in different types: aggregated, specific, generic, average. They describe different levels of specificity concerning the description of the building components as well as the representativeness of the LCA data.
ILCD 7.5 Developing generic LCI data
7.6. Selecting secondary LCI datasets
7.7 Averaging LCI data
According to the ILCD Handbook, a dataset is a generic dataset if “it has been developed using at least partly other information than those measured for the specific process. This other information can be stoichiometric or other calculation models, patents and other plans for processes or products, expert judgements etc. Generic process can aim at representing a specific process or system or an average situation.”According to ILCD, the supply mix for an average dataset is the production mix plus the import mix, i.e. the mix of what is available in the country for consumption. This applies to a specific dataset like an EPD for a product sold by a company.

Figure 14 representing the trade relations between countries, as a basis for calculating the production, consumption and supply mixes of products [ILCD 2011a]


Guidance

In practice, the LCA data for a complete LCA should closely represent the building components, products or materials, or the part of the building. The building LCA practitioner may use an existing national EPD database to collect specific EPD data on building products, depending on the requirements. Three different practical recommendations can be given for the use of data on building elements, the associated LCA data, and the currently available specific (e.g. EPD) databases.

1) Practical guidance for the use of data describing the building elements

The data describing the building components should correspond to the components implemented in the building. Please refer to the description of the complete LCA study type for more information.

Other data include building products and materials LCA data. These ‘raw’ data usually serve when deriving data for building components or parts of the building. Consistency should be ensured between the different levels of data for complete LCA (part of the building, components, products and materials).

2) Practical guidance for the use of specific LCA data for a European or national context

ILCD provisions can be consulted concerning the consumption mix of the building product. Specific data such as EPD reflects the production volume of a building product sold on a national market.

3) Practical availability of specific (e.g. EPD) databases in Europe that can be used by the practitioner

Specific EPDs may be found in available national EPD databases or European EPD databases (e.g. ECO-EPD). Examples of such databases can be found in several European countries:

France: INIES

Germany: Institut Bauen und Umwelt

UK: BRE Profiles

Spain: DAPc system

The Netherlands: MRPI

Finland: RTS

The International EPD (R) ‘The Green Yardstick’ also provides EPD data for some European countries, such as Sweden and Italy.

If specific EPDs are not available, the practitioner may use generic data or average industry data. Consultation of the LCA Resources directory of the European Commission – Joint Research Centre, section ‘Databases‘ may then be needed. Generic databases include, for example, the ELCD, GaBi and ecoinvent databases. Other generic databases developed in European countries include, for example, the German Ökobau.dat and the Swiss Catalogue Construction/KBOB databases.

Care has to be taken when using EPDs for complete LCA, as they may not include a full LCI (depending on the PCR, only environmental indicators may be required). Thus they may not allow the use of LCIA indicators outside the scope of the Product Category Rules. For example, the EN 15978 standard does not yet include land use, toxicity or ecotoxicity indicators. The same remarks apply to cut-off rules and infrastructure issues.

The LCA practitioner should be aware that the choice of LCI/LCIA datasets for complete LCA is intended primarily to be as accurate as possible for the current impact of the manufacture of a building product. However, the cut-off rules and LCI documentation may not be as comprehensive as needed by the practitioner.

For alternative goal definitions beyond the scope of EN 15804, the practitioner may need a complete LCI in order to consider a full suite of impact categories. The same applies for the cut-off criteria. In this special case, the practitioner is likely to rely on generic datasets that may be the only possible way to provide such a level of detail (LCI, cut-off rules).

At this point, there is a trade-off between using specific data for a commercial reference of a product, and maintaining a high level of detail in terms of LCI, cut-off rules etc.

G-26 Use of building physical description data

Aspect G-26 Use of building physical description data

Description
The type, the format, the level of detail and the quality of building-related data depend on the time of assessment (e.g. concept stage, basic design stage, detailed design stage, as built), on the objective of the study, and on the building’s stakeholders. Which kind of data should be used for a building LCA study?
Related
Study Goal
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Related
Study Phase
☐
Goal and scope definition
☒
Life cycle inventory analysis (LCI)
☐
Life cycle impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
Interpretation
☐
Reporting
Relevant for
New buildings

Existing buildings

Building products

Screening LCA

Simplified LCA

Complete LCA

Provisions
The data for describing the main building elements should be taken from the building’s project documentation already available at the time of the assessment; otherwise use specific documentation included in the LCA software for buildings (if relevant). Different building-related data may be used in the documentation, depending on the objective of the study and the time of the assessment. For example, for screening LCA, an average description of a building could be sufficient, whereas for complete LCA a specific and detailed description of the building should be used wherever possible. Once the building-related data are quantified, they should be associated with suitable LCA or EPD data (see aspect ‘LCA datasets’).

Rules from
EN 15978 7.5.2 Description of the physical characteristics of the building
9.4 Type of data for the assessment
The choice of the data in EN 15978 will depend on several aspects, including the stage of the building project, and the intended use or scope. According to EN 15978 the data (either the bill of quantities, a building description of components, or the LCA data) may be given in different types: aggregated, specific, generic or average. They describe different levels of specificity concerning the description of the building components as well as the representativeness of the LCA data.

Guidance

The description of the quantities of the building products may vary significantly in terms of precision between the early design of a building project and the very late stages of the project. Practitioners should always ensure that the building description is consistent between the various documents used, as the documents are not all produced at the same time, and building projects change over time. For example, it is essential to check whether the energy consumption results are based on assumptions regarding the mass of the building products, rather than the quantity take-off available in separate documentation.

Generally, in early design, the level of description is low, as the design team does not yet know exactly what the specific description of the elements will be. For instance, the reinforced concrete in early design stages is described mainly in ml or m3, with a ratio for the reinforcing steel included in the concrete.

However, during the detailed design, the level of description of the building elements is increased. At this stage, the building-related data may be more precise for some building elements (e.g. for the façades), whereas for others (e.g. the floor coverings), it may be only roughly taken into account until the actual building occupants are found.

Common units that can be found in the building’s project documentation are: ml, m2, m3, unit etc. The practitioner should be aware of the potential differences in terms of the functional or declared units of LCA data available in LCA software for buildings and some of the units of the building-related data (the quantity take-off). Wherever possible, the practitioner should use the most appropriate LCA data that correctly match the building-related data for the corresponding stage of the project.

G-28 (Buildings) / G-26 (Products) Choice of environmental indicators – Complete LCA

Aspect G-28 (Buildings) / G-26 (Products) Choice of environmental indicators – Complete LCA

Description
The choice of a set of environmental indicators should always try to avoid pollution transfer. Currently, a large number of indicators can be found in the LCA literature. They refer to different types of indicator: selected LCI indicators, midpoint life cycle impact assessment (LCIA) indicators, and endpoint LCIA indicators. Selected LCI flows can be useful in tracking some quantity of flows, e.g. the use of secondary energy throughout the product’s life cycle. These are not impact indicators directly, but they can be useful for the interpretation phase of any LCA study. Midpoint LCIA indicators (or potential indicators) make it possible to characterize different environmental problems, such as climate change, ozone depletion, photochemical ozone formation, acidification, eutrophication and resource depletion. End-point LCIA indicators refer to actual damage categories, such as damage to resources, damage to human health, and damage to the ecosystem. What are the useful and necessary environmental indicators and impact categories to be reported for an energy-efficient product or building? Which indicators and which methodology should be chosen?
Related
study objective
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Related
study phase
☐
goal and scope definition
☐
inventory analysis (LCI)
☒
impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
interpretation
☐
reporting
Relevant for
new buildings

existing buildings

building products

screening LCA

simplified LCA

complete LCA

Provisions
In general, the set of indicators should be as comprehensive as possible to avoid burden shifting. The EeBGuide does not provide predefined provisions regarding the number or type of indicators for each study type, as they depend on the goal, the scope and the context of the study. Environmental indicators to choose are given in the EN 15978 and EN 15804 standards (which are harmonized indicators between the product and the building level), and also in the ILCD Handbook, if other indicators need to be included. For complete LCA studies the environmental indicators mentioned in EN 15978 and EN 15804 should be used. However, optional indicators for impact categories not covered by the CEN standards may also be considered, if relevant for the LCA study. In this case, they may be taken from the existing LCIA methods in the ILCD Handbook.

Rules from
EN 15978 11 Calculation of the environmental indicators
EN 15804 7.2.3 Parameters describing environmental impacts
ILCD Provisions: 6.7 Preparing the basis for impact assessment

“[…] VI) MAY – LCIA methodologies: […] select complete set of single LCIA methods rather than selecting and combining individual LCIA methods”

Provisions: 7.4.3.8 Reminder flows

I) MAY – Use reminder flows to keep original information for specific purposes

II) SHALL – exclude reminder flows from impact assessment

III) SHALL – Clearly identify reminder flows in the flow name

8 Life Cycle Impact Assessment – calculating LCIA results

Provisions: 8.2 Calculation of LCIA results

ILCD Handbook – Part – Analysing of existing Environmental Impact Assessment methodologies for use in Life Cycle Assessment

4 Requirements for specific impact categories

“For some impact categories, many alternative methods have been selected. This can be seen as a sign that there is no clear consensus on how to model such a method. Clear examples are acidification, eutrophication, land use and resources.”


Guidance
The operational guidance for the environmental indicators can be split into two main aspects: the calculations rules for environmental indicators (in both the CEN TC 350 standards and in the ILCD Handbook) and the number of indicators to select, depending on the study type.

1) Calculation rules (i.e. characterization factors and associated method) for each LCIA indicator in EN 15804/EN 15978

Various LCIA methods are currently available to calculate the LCIA indicators mentioned in the CEN TC 350 standards. Recently, the ILCD Handbook has released the report ‘Characterization factors of the ILCD – Recommended Life Cycle Impact Assessment Methods’. In this report, several methods are analysed, and one is then suggested as the recommended method for each impact category. In the EeBGuide, the ILCD-recommended methods are provided for information in Appendix B for the following LCIA indicators: GWP, ODP, AP, EP, POCP and ADP (both elements and fossils). However, deviations in units are currently found between EN 15804/EN 15978 and the ILCD-recommended methods for:

– AP (acidification potential, unit kg SO2-equiv. vs. accumulated exceedance, unit mole H+ eq);

– EP (eutrophication potential, unit: kg PO43--equiv. vs. accumulated exceedance, unit: mole Neq).

A new method is now suggested for the POCP calculations based on [Van Zelm 2008]. Other LCIA methods have been used so far for POCP calculations: for example, the CML 2002 approach based on [Derwent 1998]. As a result, care has to be taken, and the method used for LCIA indicators should be clearly stated.

PS: Please note that the ADP guidance is given in a separate aspect.

Harmonization of the LCIA indicators is expected soon. The aspect will be revised once there are agreed methods between CEN and ILCD.

2) Calculation rules for each indicator describing resources use and additional information (wastes etc.) in EN 15804/EN 15978

According to the ILCD Handbook, these flows are called ‘reminder flows’ (see ILCD rules above). The practitioner and LCA tool developer may be aware that, so far, not all the resource use indicators can be easily determined. In fact, the background databases used in LCA studies do not provide this information in a consistent way (e.g. ‘use of non-renewable primary energy excluding primary energy resources used by a raw material’). Others are potentially more easily available (e.g. ‘use of secondary fuels’). As the practitioner cannot influence the background data, this problem ultimately needs to be solved by the data providers.

3) Calculation rules for optional indicators (taken from the ILCD Handbook)

Currently there is no agreement on a single calculation method for impact categories not covered in CEN TC 350 (but available in the ILCD Handbook), such as land use, toxicity or ecotoxicity. The type of LCIA modelling between midpoint indicators and endpoint indicators is subject to discussion. Therefore the EeBGuide does not provide strict provisions on these aspects. Please consult the corresponding aspects for more detailed guidance on those aspects that are not mandatory in the EeBGuide.

4) Number of indicators to consider, depending on the study type.

To select a relevant set of indicators, the practitioner should also try to have indicators covering the three area of protection: resources, ecosystems and human health. The indicators of EN 15804/EN 15978 correspond to these area of protection, but do not include all the impact categories, as some are still being debated within the LCA community. Additional aspects (see ‘Biodiversity’, ‘Land use’, ‘Toxicity and ecotoxicity’ etc.) provide guidance for the practitioner who would like to use them.

For complete LCA studies, the full list of impact categories in EN 15978/EN 15804 should be used as well as missing categories taken from the ILCD Handbook if relevant for the goal of the study.

G-29 (Buildings) / G-27 (Products) Abiotic resources depletion indicator

Aspect G-29 (Buildings) / G-27 (Products) Abiotic resources depletion indicator

Description
In LCA, different indicators can be used for assessing the use of resources. These can be based on a thermodynamic approach (use of energy or exergy indicators), on a mass flow approach (use of a total mass requirement indicator), on a surplus of energy that will be needed for future extractions (ecoindicator approach), or on a scarcity approach (use of the ADP indicator developed at CML Leiden). According to the ILCD Handbook, the CML method uses the abiotic depletion potential (ADP), given in kg of antimony equivalents, to be multiplied by the amount of a given resource extracted. For ADP, the annual production of the resource (the extraction rate) is divided by the reserves squared, and the result is divided by the same ratio for the reference resource, antimony [ILCD, 2011a]. The CEN TC 350 standards recommend using the ADP indicator, but different forms of APD can be used, depending on the type of reserve and the available extraction rates. Which indicator and assumptions should be applied in this guidance document?
Study
objective
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Study
phase
☐
goal and scope definition
☐
inventory analysis (LCI)
☒
impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
interpretation
☐
reporting
Relevant for
new buildings

existing buildings

building products

screening LCA

simplified LCA

complete LCA

Provisions
Adopt the provision of the indicators and methodology mentioned in EN 15978 and EN 15804 (‘Depletion of abiotic resources-elements’ and ‘Depletion of abiotic resources-fossil fuels’). EN 15804 refers to CML (Institute of Environmental Sciences Faculty of Science University of Leiden, Netherlands) as the characterization factor for ADP (elements and fossil), and the characterization factors for ADP fossil fuels are based on net calorific values at the point of extraction of the fossil fuels.

Rules from:
EN 15978:
12.5 List of indicators used for assessment and expression of results
11.1.2 Indicators describing environmental impacts
EN 15804:
6.5 Impact assessment
7.2.3 Parameters describing environmental impacts
ILCD:
8 Life cycle impact assessment – calculating LCIA results
Provisions: 8.2 Calculation of LCIA results
ILCD Handbook – Part – Analysing of existing environmental impact assessment methodologies for use in life cycle assessment

4.11 Resource depletion

“For some impact categories, many alternative methods have been selected. This can be seen as a sign that there is no clear consensus on how to model such a method. Clear examples are acidification, eutrophication, land use and resources.”

ILCD Handbook: Recommendations for life cycle impact assessment in the European context

3.11. Resources depletion

3.11.7 Recommended default method for category 2

“The CML method is recommended in the ILCD framework since it captures scarcity by including extraction as well as reserves of a given resource. Characterization factors are given for metals, fossil fuels and, in the case of reserve base and economic reserves, mineral compounds [Oers 2002]. In addition, the method covers most of the substances/materials identified as critical by the European Commission’s Ad-hoc Working Group on defining critical raw materials (European Commission 2010).”

[Oers 2002] give characterization factors for economic reserves, reserve base, and ultimate reserves. The characterization factors given for the reserve base are recommended, as this reflects a longer time horizon and the possibility of improvement in mining technology, making feasible the exploitation of previously sub-economic deposits.


Guidance
Practitioners should keep in mind that for the LCIA indicator ‘Abiotic depletion’ there is a methodology available that provides different assumptions regarding the estimate of reserves, i.e. ultimate, base or economic [Guinée 2001], [Oers 2002].

So far, EN 15804 and EN 15978 do not specify which kinds of reserve should be considered for the ADP calculation. Over the past few years, most LCA or EPD data have reported the ADP (both fossil and elements) based on ultimate reserves according to [Guinée 2001]. Recently, the ILCD Handbook released the report ‘Recommendations for life cycle impact assessment in the European context’ (First edition, December 2010) [EC 2011]. In this guide, it recommended that the base reserve be used for the ADP calculation for all the elements (aluminium, copper, etc.). This guidance will be updated when EN 15804 and EN 15978 are revised.

The ADP (fossil or elements) characterization factors based upon the CML 2002 method can be downloaded from: http://cml.leiden.edu/research/industrialecology/researchprojects/finished/new-dutch-lca-guide.html. In addition, another link provides the latest version of the characterization factors for the CML 2002 impact categories: http://cml.leiden.edu/software/data-cmlia.html.

In the construction sector, such an indicator (ADP) may be adapted to take into account the local depletion of resources such as gravel. This is still a research topic but more information can be found in recent scientific papers, e.g. [Habert 2009].

G-30 (Buildings) / G-28 (Products) Land use indicator

Aspect G-30 (Buildings) / G-28 (Products) Land use indicator

Description
Land-use change is linked to human activities such as the exploitation of land for agricultural, industrial, residential, recreational, or other purposes. Currently, several LCIA methods exist, providing both midpoint and endpoint characterization factors. According to the ILCD Handbook, the midpoint characterization factor for land use, in the earliest stage of the cause–effect chain, is usually taken as the amount and quality deficit of land occupied or transformed. Some midpoint methods use indicators such as soil structure, soil pH or soil organic carbon. The endpoint characterization factor refers mostly to the quantity of species lost due to land use, or to the change in net primary production (NPP) of the land used [ILCD 2011a].

Based on these different approaches, should a land-use indicator be included in the LCA of a product or a building?

Study
objective
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Study
phase
☐
goal and scope definition
☐
inventory analysis (LCI)
☒
impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
interpretation
☐
reporting
Relevant for
new buildings

existing buildings

building products

screening LCA

simplified LCA

complete LCA

Provisions
Land use should not be included as a mandatory indicator, as there is currently no agreed scientific method available (as also mentioned in the EN 15804 and EN 15978 standards). Yet, if the goal and scope of the study mention the use of an LCIA indicator for land use, then the indicator that is used for the assessment needs to be described and referenced.

Rules from:
EN 15978:
11. Calculation of the environmental indicators
“Note: Indicators for which there is no scientifically agreed calculation method within the context of LCA e.g. human health, ecotoxicity, biodiversity, land use are not included”
ILCD:
8 Life cycle impact assessment – calculating LCIA results
Provisions: 8.2 Calculation of LCIA results
13 Annex B: Calculation of CO2 emissions from land transformation
ILCD Handbook: Analysing of existing environmental impact assessment methodologies for use in life cycle assessment
“For some impact categories, many alternative methods have been selected. This can be seen as a sign that there is no clear consensus on how to model such a method. Clear examples are acidification, eutrophication, land use and resources.”

ILCD Handbook: Recommendations for life cycle impact assessment in the European context

3.10 Land use

Existing methods for land use that can be used at the midpoint level include: [Baitz 2002] which was further developed by [Bos 2008], [Milà I Canals 2007], [De Schryver 2009] and [Beck 2010].


Guidance
If land-use change is intended to be assessed, it is recommended that recent LCA literature be consulted to identify a feasible and appropriate indicator. Such literature may include:

– the analysis of available existing LCIA methods for land use provided by the ILCD Handbook (report available online: http://lct.jrc.ec.europa.eu/pdf-directory/ILCD-Handbook-LCIA-Background-analysis-online-12March2010.pdf);
– the results of the UNEP/SETAC working group on ‘Operational Characterization Factors for Land Use in Life Cycle Impact Assessment’ (LULCIA) [Beck 2010]
– several publications in the International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment, such as a recent paper on the ‘Principles of inventory of land use on a global scale’ [Koellner 2012].

This aspect will need to be revised when an approved method is available.

G-31 (Buildings) / G-29 (Products) Biodiversity indicator

Aspect G-31 (Buildings) / G-29 (Products) Biodiversity indicator

Description
The loss of species and their diversity caused by destruction of their habitat has become one of the pivotal topics of environmental political actions in recent years. For years the scientific community has been working on completing a portfolio of considered environmental impacts, including taking biodiversity into account as a subject of protection.

Which indicator and which methodology should be used?

Study
objective
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Study
phase
☐
goal and scope definition
☐
inventory analysis (LCI)
☒
impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
interpretation
☐
reporting
Relevant for
new buildings

existing buildings

building products

screening LCA

simplified LCA

complete LCA

Provisions
Adopt provision of the indicators mentioned in EN 15804 and EN 15978. The standards explicitly exclude biodiversity, because so far no scientifically agreed method is available. Yet, if the goal and scope of the study mention the use of an LCIA indicator for biodiversity, the indicator that is used for the assessment needs to be described.

Rules from:
EN 15978:
11. Calculation of the environmental indicators
“Note: Indicators for which there is no scientifically agreed calculation method within the context of LCA e.g. human health, ecotoxicity, biodiversity, land use are not included.”
ILCD:
8 Life cycle impact assessment – calculating LCIA results
Provisions: 8.2 Calculation of LCIA results
ILCD Handbook: Recommendations for life cycle impact assessment in the European context
3.2.3 Measuring biodiversity loss
Existing methods for biodiversity that can be used at the midpoint level include: [Baitz 2002], which was further developed by [Bos 2008], [Milà i Canals 2007], [De Schryver 2009] and [Beck 2010].

Guidance
Currently discussions are ongoing about biodiversity indicators and methodology. So far there is no scientifically sound and commonly agreed method available. This aspect will need to be revised if there are new outcomes from the discussions.

G-32 (Buildings) / G-30 (Products) Human toxicity and ecotoxicity indicators

Aspect G-32 (Buildings) / G-30 (Products) Human toxicity and ecotoxicity indicators

Description
LCIA methodologies usually include midpoint or endpoint indicators for three area of protection: resources, human health and ecosystem. For the two last areas of protection, different indicators are currently available to assess the ecotoxicity and toxicity effects related to a product or a building life cycle. They classify the multimedia fate of chemicals into ecological compartments such as air, water and soil. On the one hand, accounting for toxicity and ecotoxicity effects allows a more comprehensive assessment in terms of the completeness of the set of indicators. On the other hand, these two impact categories are subject to very high uncertainties. Several indicators have been developed by the LCA community, which can lead to different conclusions [Van Caneghem 2010]. Should toxicity and ecotoxicity indicators be used in an LCA of buildings?
Related
study objective
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Related
study phase
☐
goal and scope definition
☐
inventory analysis (LCI)
☒
impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
interpretation
☐
reporting
Relevant for
new buildings

existing buildings

building products

screening LCA

simplified LCA

complete LCA

Provisions
Adopt provision of the indicators mentioned in the EN 15804 and EN 15978 standards. These do not include toxicity or ecotoxicity methods, because there is so far no scientifically agreed method available. Yet, if the goal and scope of the study mention the use of an LCIA indicator for toxicity and ecotoxicity, the indicator that is used for the assessment needs to be described.

Rules from
EN 15978 11. Calculation of the environmental indicators
“Note: Indicators for which there is no scientifically agreed calculation method within the context of LCA e.g. human health, ecotoxicity, biodiversity, land use are not included”
ILCD 8 Life cycle impact assessment – calculating LCIA results
Provisions: 8.2 Calculation of LCIA results
ILCD Handbook: Recommendations for life cycle impact assessment in the European context

3.3. Human toxicity
Existing methods for human toxicity aspects that can be used at the midpoint and endpoint level include: USEtox [Rosenbaum 2008] ReCiPe [Huijbregts 2009], IMPACT2002+ [Jolliet 2003] TRACI [Bare 2003], EDIP [Potting 2005], CML 2002 [Huijbregts 2000] and MEEuP [Kemna 2005]

ILCD states that “The use of USEtox as multimedia model, combining chemical fate and exposure with toxicological data, is recommended for midpoint indicators” for human toxicity.

ILCD states that “For the endpoint characterization, it is proposed as an initial basis to apply the most recent values that are proposed by Huijbregts et al. (2005a) using disability adjusted life years (DALYs)”

3.3.5 Discussion on uncertainties and the importance of spatial-temporal differentiation

3.9 Ecotoxicity

Existing methods for ecotoxicity aspects that can be used at the midpoint level include three groups according to their fate modelling:

1. Full multimedia fate modelling: USEtox [Rosenbaum 2008], ReCiPe [Huijbregts 2009], IMPACT2002+ [Jolliet 2003], TRACI [Bare 2003]

2. Partial fate modelling – Environmental key properties: EDIP

3. No fate modelling: Swiss Ecoscarcity [Frischknecht 2008] and MEEuP [Kemna 2005]

ILCD states that “USEtox is preferred as the recommended default method for the midpoint evaluation of freshwater ecotoxicity impacts. This is equally consistent with the model recommended for toxicity impacts for humans. It results from a consensus building effort amongst related modellers and, hence, the underlying principles reflect common and agreed recommendations from these experts.” ILCD states that “No available method is recommended to address marine and terrestrial ecotoxicity.”

Endpoint level for ecotoxicity includes: EPS2000 [Steen 1999], ReCiPe [Huijbregts 2009] and IMPACT 2002+ [Jolliet 2003].

3.9.4 Discussion on uncertainties and the importance of spatial differentiation


Guidance
The LCA practitioner in the building sector should be aware of the existing and recommended LCIA methods for assessing toxicity and ecotoxicity aspects. Current uncertainties are substantial for these impact categories, although it is generally recognized that it is better to have one indicator than no indicator at all for an impact category. The LCA practitioner in the building sector should also be aware that current efforts are under way at the international level to harmonize the toxicity and ecotoxicity models: see e.g. the USE-oTox model. The latest developments in LCIA for human toxicity have included a new compartment ‘indoor air emissions’ in the USETox model (which is recommended for use by the ILCD). Accounting for indoor air emissions is increasingly relevant, as human beings spend most of their time inside buildings. Such new LCIA developments have to be connected to the EeBGuide aspect of Module B1 ‘Release of dangerous substances to air during the use stage’. The previous European project LoRe-LCA describes the basic concepts of such models in more detail (report available online). Practitioners should also keep in mind that national EPD programmes may also recommend using toxicity indicators that are not included in the core European PCR (EN 15804 and EN 15978). In this case, the practitioner should use them for national LCA studies (if relevant). This guidance will be précised and updated when the EN 15804/EN 15978 are revised.

G-33 (Buildings) / G-31 (Products) Ionizing radiation indicator

Aspect G-33 (Buildings) / G-31 (Products) Ionizing radiation indicator

Description
‘Ionizing radiation’ is an impact category in LCA related to the damage to human health and ecosystems that is linked to the emissions of radionuclides throughout a product or building life cycle. In the building sector, they can be linked to the use of nuclear power in an electricity mix. LCIA methodologies (such as Eco-indicator99, IMPACT 2002+, ReCiPe) currently calculate the ionizing radiation effect of a product’s or a building’s life cycle. Should an ionizing radiation indicator be used in an LCA of buildings?
Related
study objective
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Related
study phase
☐
goal and scope definition
☐
inventory analysis (LCI)
☒
impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
interpretation
☐
reporting
Relevant for
new buildings

existing buildings

building products

screening LCA

simplified LCA

complete LCA

Provisions
Adopt provision of the indicators mentioned in EN 15804 and EN 15978 standards. They do not include an ionizing radiation indicator, because so far no scientifically agreed method is available. Yet, if the goal and scope of the study mention the use of an LCIA indicator for ionizing radiation, then the indicator that is used for the assessment needs to be described. As a proxy indicator, EN 15804 and EN 15978 provide a flow indicator for quantifying the radioactive waste (expressed in m3). This indicator should be used, particularly in a national context that relies heavily on nuclear energy, to avoid shifting of burdens (if only the GWP indicator is used).

Rules from
EN 15978 11. Calculation of the environmental indicators
“Note: Indicators describing emission of ionizing radiation and their impact on human health and/or ecosystems in LCA level are intended for consideration during the revision of this European standard.”
ILCD 8 Life cycle impact assessment – calculating LCIA results
Provisions: 8.2 Calculation of LCIA results
ILCD Handbook: Recommendations for life cycle impact assessment in the European context
Existing methods for ionizing radiation that can be used at the midpoint and endpoint levels include [Frischknecht 2000]. ILCD states that “to our knowledge this is the only method that meets the general requirements for a quantitative approach. The fate and exposure model has been based on the ExternE work carried out by Dreicer et al., 1995, who described the routine atmospheric and liquid discharges in the French nuclear fuel cycle. Data from UNSCEAR (1993) were used for three additional radionuclides.”

Guidance
This guidance will be updated when EN 15804 and EN 15978 are revised.

G-34 (Buildings) / G-32 (Products) Water consumption as a new impact category

Aspect G-34 (Buildings) / G-32 (Products) Water consumption as a new impact category

Description
The water consumed during the life cycle of a product or a building can have an impact on the environment. This impact actually depends on the geographical location. For example, in some regions of the world, the same amount of consumed water may have different environmental impacts, depending on the available water resources. The current practice in LCA is that water flows are classified only according to their type (ocean, river, groundwater etc.).

In this context, should a factor for regional availability be included? Should the scarcity of water be considered? What type of water (e.g. drinking water) should be considered? How should water demand be classified regarding its origin?

Study
objective
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Study
phase
☐
goal and scope definition
☐
inventory analysis (LCI)
☒
impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
interpretation
☐
reporting
Relevant for
new buildings

existing buildings

building products

screening LCA

simplified LCA

complete LCA

Provisions
As there is no commonly agreed method for assessing the impact related to water consumption, scarcity of water is not considered at present. The provisions of EN 15804 and EN 15978 should be used, i.e. use of the indicator ‘net fresh water’. Yet, if the goal and scope of the study mention the use of an LCIA indicator for water consumption, the indicator that is used for the assessment needs to be described.

Rules from:
EN 15978:
11 Calculation of the environmental indicators
EN 15804:
7.2.3 Parameters describing environmental impacts

ILCD:
8 Life cycle impact assessment – calculating LCIA results
Provisions: 8.2 Calculation of LCIA results
Provisions: 7.4.3.6 Resource elementary flows


Guidance
1) Practical guidance for the use of EN 15804 indicator

Two cases can be differentiated for guidance: practical calculation of the LCI indicator (currently provided in the CEN TC 350 standards) or available references for the use of a new impact category indicator for water consumption.

– If the ‘net fresh water’ indicator is used according to EN 15804 and EN 15978, it should be calculated as the difference between the water input and water output from a product system. Thus cooling and turbine-use inventory flows are not to be accounted for in the indicator. Salted water is also excluded, as this category deals only with ‘fresh’ water.

2) Practical guidance for the use of a water indicator as a new impact category

If a water indicator is to be considered as an optional impact category, it has to be documented separately. For more information, please consult the following sources. Results from the UNEP/SETAC working group ‘Assessment of Freshwater Use within LCA’ (WULCA) should be considered, and are especially relevant. Scientific papers on the latest developments of the water impact category can also be consulted.

At the standardization level, the ISO is also working on a new standard on water footprint: ISO/CD 14046 Life cycle assessment – Water footprint – Requirements and guidelines.

Revision of this aspect is required if a generally accepted method is available – and used by the EN 15804/15978 standards.

Please also note that some of the EPD programmes consider the inclusion of water in one way or another. Additional information on methodologies can be found in such EPD programmes. However, the various data sources could refer to different methodologies for the calculation of a water indicator.

G-35 (Buildings) / G-33 (Products) Normalization of indicators

Aspect G-35 (Buildings) / G-33 (Products) Normalization of indicators

Description
According to the ILCD Handbook, the normalization step refers to the expression of indicators (LCIA, midpoints or endpoints) relative to a common reference by dividing the indicator results by the respective reference value. Different normalization factors can be applied in practice to help the interpretation of results in the building sector.

How can this issue be considered within this guidance document?

Study
objective
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Study
phase
☐
goal and scope definition
☐
inventory analysis (LCI)
☐
impact assessment (LCIA)
☒
interpretation
☐
reporting
Relevant for
new buildings

existing buildings

building products

screening LCA

simplified LCA

complete LCA

Provisions
The normalization of indicators (which are the LCA results of products and buildings) should remain an optional stage, according to ISO 14044. However, in certain circumstances the normalization of results may be very helpful for the LCA practitioner and/or the decision-maker, and assist interpretation of the study results.

Rules from:
ILCD:
“Provisions: 6.7 Preparing the basis for the impact assessment […]
Normalisation and weighting: […]
XIII) MAY – Results interpretation: Normalisation and weighting are in addition optional steps under ISO 14044:2006 that are recommended to support the results interpretation (see part 6.3.6)”

“Provisions: 10.3 Three levels of reporting requirements […]
IV) SHALL – Main report, with the following aspects […]

IV.e) Life cycle impact assessment results calculation, where applicable: […]

IV.e.vi) data and indicator results reached prior to any normalization, grouping or weighting shall be made available together with the normalized, grouped or weighted results.

IV.e) Life cycle interpretation: […]

IV.f.iv) full transparency in terms of value choices, rationales and expert judgements.


Guidance
If the normalization step is considered for product or building LCA case studies it should be carried out in line with the ILCD Handbook. The assumptions should be documented as transparently as possible. Two types of normalization of results can be used in practice, answering two types of objective:

1) Help to identify the most relevant indicators among the global set of indicators

In this case, the LCA results are scaled to a common geographical reference (e.g. at the European level, or in some national contexts) and for a given time period (e.g. 1 year). Generally speaking, normalization factors are available at the world, European and national levels per indicator per year. Doing this will enable the practitioner to identify the key indicators that are driven by the building sector, and in the specific study. It is a way to identify hotspots, and reduce for example the number of indicators from EN 15804/EN 15978 or other indicators available in the ILCD Handbook (if relevant). The main issue is to be able to obtain the normalization factors for each indicator. The LCIA method usually provides normalization factors for the midpoint, such as the global warming potential (GWP), or endpoint indicators.

For example, the CML 2002 method provides normalization factors for The Netherlands (1997), Western Europe (1995) and the world (1995). Other impact assessment methods, such as Eco-indicator 99, IMPACT 2002 and ReCiPe, also provide normalization values.

Some of these LCIA methods may be used in a building LCA in addition to the baseline indicators given in the EN 15978/EN 15804 standards. Previous European projects have provided the values for these normalization factors through their online deliverables.

Examples of normalization factors that can be used for the French context (mean impacts per person and per year) can be found below:

Mid-point indicators Unit equiv-person /year Source
GWP kg eq-CO2 8680 CITEPA
AP kg eq-SO2 62.3 CITEPA
POCP kg eq-C2H4 19.7 CITEPA
EP kg eq-PO43- 38.1 IFEN
Other indicators Unit eq-person Source
Primary energy demand MJ 48 670 Observatoire de l’énergie
Water consumption m3 339 IFEN
Radioactive waste dm3 0.51 ANDRA
Other wastes kg-eq 10400 ADEME

[Peuportier 2008]

Example of normalization factors that can be used for the European context can be found in the BRE Environmental Profiles Methodology.

A comprehensive set of normalization factors are described in detail in LoRe-LCA.

2) Comparison of LCA results with existing benchmarks

In the building sector, practitioners may be asked to comply with a set of targets for overall environmental performance. For example, an architect or a real estate manager may need to answer the following question: “Does the studied building perform well compared with current best and good practice?” In this particular case, the LCA results can be normalized to existing reference values to compare design alternatives with current practice.

Appendix B provides some first reference values for buildings for Germany and France.