Skip to main content

Tag: Study type: Complete LCA

A-01 Use and adaptation of available cradle-to-gate and cradle-to-grave LCA or EPD data for building products and technical equipment

Aspect A-01 Use and adaptation of available cradle-to-gate and cradle-to-grave LCA or EPD data for building products and technical equipment

Description
Different LCA data describing the impacts of raw materials supply, transport and manufacturing (cradle-to-gate data) can be used in practice, depending on the goal and scope, on their availabilities in LCA or EPD databases, and on the geographical location of the building. In addition, they need to be adapted, e.g. information for the gate-to-grave impacts, or adaptation of the cradle-to-gate data to a different context.

Which LCA or EPD data should be used in a building LCA study? How can they be adapted if they are not fully appropriate?

Study
objective
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Study
phase
☒
goal and scope definition
☐
inventory analysis (LCI)
☐
impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
interpretation
☐
reporting
Relevant for
new buildings

existing buildings

building products

screening LCA

simplified LCA

complete LCA

Provisions
The practitioner should use existing LCA or EPD databases for selecting cradle-to-gate data or cradle-to-grave data. As far as possible, the practitioner should use a single database for deriving all the data on building products and technical equipment, or otherwise make sure that the building products and technical equipment data are based on identical assumptions.

The adaptation of cradle-to-gate data should use consistent rules for building LCA modelling.


Rules from:
EN 15978:
10.2.2 Adaptation of cradle to gate (product stage) information
10.2.3 Adaptation from gate to grave information (Modules A4 to C4) and Module D

Guidance
The choice of LCI/LCIA datasets depends on the goal and scope of the study. Please refer to the corresponding general aspects (in the inventory analysis section). The existing LCA data should be handled with care, as they may have different system boundaries. They also can be used in different contexts, which means they will need to be adapted.

1) Guidance for the use of existing databases on building products or technical equipment

Generally speaking, the use of a single database is highly recommended when conducting a building LCA study, so as not to bias the results (e.g. in comparative assertions). Existing LCA or EPD databases are often not comparable, owing to differences in assumptions and methodologies.

However, some data (e.g. for technical equipment) may not have been calculated using the same rules (or the same PCR) as other data (e.g. building products). The use of two different databases can be justified in this case if the main conclusions of the study are not affected by the use of data coming from different sources. Alternatively, the practitioner may prefer to rely on a single database, even if not all the building products and technical equipment have corresponding LCI/LCIA data.

2) Adaptation of cradle-to-gate data for a building LCA study

The cradle-to-gate data can be adapted either for the production stage (e.g. French or German cradle-to-gate data used in a neighbouring country) or for the additional life cycle stages (Modules A4, A5, C and D).

Sometimes data are already presented as cradle-to-gate data: for example, the French EPD database (INIES) provides for some EPD cradle-to-grave results without information for the cradle-to-grave stage. In this case, the practitioner should carefully check whether the scenario and the boundaries for the gate-to-grave stages are relevant for the goal and scope of the study (e.g. according to EN 15804).

3) Use of scenarios for gate-to-grave data for a building LCA study

Scenarios are needed to assess the cradle-to-grave impacts depending on the goal and scope of the study (please refer to the corresponding aspects in every life cycle stage for each study type).

Even if cradle-to-grave data are available (e.g. French EPD for building products), the scenarios included in these data should be checked for consistency with the scenarios representative of the building under study.

If the EPD is broken down into different life cycle stages, the practitioner can then select the cradle-to-gate EPD information and adapt the gate-to-grave information.

Scenarios for gate-to-grave impacts need to use default values (or else specific values) especially for:

Modules A4 and A5:
– the transportation distance from the factory to the building site (in km);
– the LCA data for transportation processes (e.g. lorry, train);
– the construction losses of building product (in %).

Module B – Use stage:
– the reference service life of the product (in years);
– other aspects (if relevant).

Module C – End-of-life stage:
– the share of end-of-life scenarios i.e. landfill, recycling, incineration (w/o heat recovery) for each type of building material;
– the corresponding LCA data.

Module D – Benefits and loads beyond the system boundary:
– the share of reuse, recovery and recycling potential for each type of building material;
– the corresponding LCA data.

Guidance for each module (and corresponding parameters) can be found in the corresponding chapter (Modules A, B, C and D); if not, the practitioner can use the scenarios proposed in building LCA tools (such as EQUER or ELODIE in France), or in building certification schemes.

A-02 Transport of staff in the supply of raw materials

Aspect A-02 Transport of staff in the supply of raw materials

Description
Is it relevant to consider the transport of staff during the extraction and manufacturing life cycle stages?
Study
objective
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Study
phase
☒
goal and scope definition
☐
inventory analysis (LCI)
☐
impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
interpretation
☐
reporting
Relevant for
new buildings

existing buildings

building products

screening LCA

simplified LCA

complete LCA

Provisions
Typically, the transport of staff is not included, owing to its lack of significance in relation to the use of energy within the cut-off rules. National EPD programmes may have individual rules on this matter, and for improved consistency with the EPDs of one programme (e.g. of the national EPD programme), it may be advisable to apply such rules.

Rules from:
EN 15804 6.3.5 Criteria for the exclusion of inputs and outputs

Guidance
Screening and simplified LCA: Transport of staff in the supply of raw materials should not be included.

Complete LCA: Unless the energy used for transport of staff for any individual process is likely to exceed 1% of the primary energy requirement for that process, it is not necessary to collect data from staff on their journey to and from the extraction or manufacturing site. Significance could be reviewed if necessary by considering costs as a proxy for primary energy, although it should be recognized that petrol and diesel are often highly taxed relative to electricity and natural gas.

A-03 Transport of raw materials to the manufacturer

Aspect A-03 Transport of raw materials to the manufacturer

Description
Several raw materials are needed for manufacturing a building product. Depending on the number of raw materials and the availabilities of information from the suppliers, it may be difficult to account for the transport of raw materials in an accurate way. However, this stage of the life cycle may be relevant if the suppliers are located far away from the manufacturing plant. How should the transport of raw materials to the manufacturer be considered for a product LCA?
Study
objective
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Study
phase
☒
goal and scope definition
☐
inventory analysis (LCI)
☐
impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
interpretation
☐
reporting
Relevant for
new buildings

existing buildings

building products

screening LCA

simplified LCA

complete LCA

Provisions
Transport of raw materials to the manufacturer should be included in Module A2 though it may be considered not relevant according to the cut-off rules (e.g. from EN 15804). Concerning the use of data, the provisions on data quality as given above should be considered (data quality, ILCD entry level, use of consistent data sources for comparative assertions).

Rules from:
EN 15804 6.3.4.2 Product stage

Guidance
Within Modules A1–A3, transport is generally a significant impact only for materials with very low manufacturing impact – aggregates and timber, for example. Module A2 includes only transport to the manufacturing site from the previous production or extraction process. Earlier transport journeys are included in Module A1. Module A2 is mandatory in any cradle-to-gate EPD. National EPD programmes may have more specific rules on this topic. The main issue for the practitioner is collection of data on the distances between suppliers and the manufacturer. Generally speaking, these data should be available, and should be requested. However, if data are missing, it is recommended that default values, e.g. from national EPD programmes and PCR, be used; otherwise the practitioner’s own default values should be used (which should be subjected to sensitivity analysis).

A-03 Accounting for technical building equipment – complete LCA

Aspect A-03 Accounting for technical building equipment – complete LCA

Description
Different types of technical building equipment can be included in building LCAs: e.g. boilers for heating, air-conditioning systems for cooling, duct networks for ventilation, solar panels for hot water, lifts, lighting etc. The development of energy-efficient buildings has meant that the relative share of the embodied impacts has recently increased, leading to more consistent modelling of the related impacts of building products and technical equipment. In addition, the LCA model should be consistent: if, for example, the PV-related energy consumption is included within Module B6, then the impacts of the PV manufacture should be accounted for in Modules A1–A3.
Study
objective
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Study
phase
☒
goal and scope definition
☐
inventory analysis (LCI)
☐
impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
interpretation
☐
reporting
Relevant for
new buildings

existing buildings

building products

screening LCA

simplified LCA

complete LCA

Provisions
For complete LCA, technical building equipment should be included. If LCA or EPD data are available at the European or national level, they should be included using specific data (e.g. based on industry EPD); otherwise, if no specific data are available for the context of the study, generic data should be used as proxy. This aspect is considered in accordance with the LCA study type: all of the technical equipment should be included in the context of a complete LCA, unless they fall under cut-off criteria.

Rules from:
EN 15978: 7.5.2 Description of the physical characteristics of the building

Guidance
The practitioner should use detailed calculation for complete LCA based on specific data (e.g. EPD), or else generic data (e.g. taken from generic LCA databases) for the technical systems:

• sanitary systems (water, waste water, piping, pump and fixed equipment);
• fixed firefighting systems;
• heating and hot water systems;
• mechanical ventilation and air conditioning;
• fixed lighting systems;
• electrical supply systems (small power, wiring, etc.);
• communication and security systems;
• transportation inside the building (lifts, escalators);
• drainage system; etc.

The practitioner should be aware that these elements of a building can have a significant impact.

Studies in the UK have estimated that the as-installed embodied impact of mechanical and electrical services is a little over 100 kg CO2e/m2 in offices, but can be as high as 240 kg CO2e/m2, with proportions of as-built embodied carbon for all buildings ranging from 4% to 25%, depending on building type. Similar conclusions were reported in the French HQE performance study [Lebert 2012], and in a recent scientific paper.

A-05 Transport of products to the construction site – complete LCA

Aspect A-05 Transport of products to the construction site – complete LCA

Description
This aspect is related to the transport of building products from the manufacturer’s production plant (or from regional storage) to the construction site. In practice, the assessment of transportation impact depends on the number of manufacturers or the number of regional storage providing a given building product. Such detailed information may be impossible to obtain without close cooperation with the building industry.

Should the transport of products to construction site be included? What could the transportation distance be for each building product? Should losses be allowed for?

Study
objective
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Study
phase
☒
goal and scope definition
☐
inventory analysis (LCI)
☐
impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
interpretation
☐
reporting
Relevant for
new buildings

existing buildings

building products

screening LCA

simplified LCA

complete LCA

Provisions
Transport of products to the construction site should be included for complete LCA.

The practitioner should use specific transport distances and load factors, or average distances and load factors if data are missing. The rules provided in EN 15804 should be applied. This includes the impacts of the transport and the impacts of any transport-related losses of material and its disposal (i.e. the impact of manufacturing material that is wasted as a result of transport and the impact of disposing of the waste). Losses should be documented, where these occur.


Rules from:
EN 15978:
7.4.3.2 Boundary of the Transport to and from site (Module A4)

EN 15804:
6.2.3 A4-A5, Construction process stage, information modules


Guidance
The practitioner should use specific data, such as that available in national EPD programmes (e.g. such specific data are available in France). Data on distance traveled and mode of transport (road, rail, sea container etc.) should be collected for each input material and waste generated. Transports should be covered all the way from the producer or to waste treatment, not just from a depot or storage warehouse. For example, the transport of timber from the sawmill in Scandinavia should be included, not just from the local timber merchant’s depot. Unless transport is likely to be very significant, generic datasets for transport per tonne-kilometre can be used. These take account of typical vehicle size, fuel efficiency, typical loading, and percentage of empty return journeys. More detailed data on the number of deliveries, size of truck, Euroclass, actual load, return journey etc. can be gathered and used to generate more specific data, but this is rarely useful unless the transport phase is particularly important. Impacts of waste that is created within the transport phase should be considered. This means that if material is wasted during this phase, its manufacturing impact and the impacts of disposal should both be considered in Module A4.

1) Specific guidance for building LCA studies
Specific distances should be collected and used for complete LCA of buildings, otherwise default average transport distances of 300 km can be assumed for all building products, based on previous works [Nemry 2008; Lasvaux 2010]. However, most building products, particularly bulk products such as aggregates and ready-mixed concrete, are likely to travel shorter distances. For example, Eurostat freight transport statistics show that, for almost all member states, more than 50% (by mass) of ‘Other non-metallic mineral products’ travel less than 50 km per trip.

2) Specific guidance for product LCA studies
The practitioner interested in obtaining detailed guidance on transport distances and load factors of lorries can look for PCR documents of national EPD programmes, and in national transport statistics.

A-08 Land preparation and earthwork during the construction process – complete LCA

Aspect A-08 Land preparation and earthwork during the construction process – complete LCA

Description
This aspect relates to the impact of site preparation, including the fuel consumption of, for example skid-steer loaders or bulldozers during the groundworks and landscaping. Under the specific goal and scope, this aspect might be interesting for, say, a construction company that needs to identify the hotspots of its construction site. Should the land preparation and earthwork during the construction process be considered in the context of a complete LCA?
Study
objective
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Study
phase
☒
goal and scope definition
☐
inventory analysis (LCI)
☐
impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
interpretation
☐
reporting
Relevant for
new buildings

existing buildings

building products

screening LCA

simplified LCA

complete LCA

Provisions
The land preparation and earthwork should be included in complete LCA if they are relevant for the goal and scope of the study (e.g. a construction company might have more interest than a building designer in this aspect).

Rules from:
EN 15978:
7.4.3 Boundaries of the construction process stage
8.5 Scenarios for the construction process stage (Modules A4–A5)

According to the rules from EN 15978, the system boundary for the construction process shall include the groundworks and landscaping.


Guidance
The practitioner should use detailed calculation (based on specific data) for complete LCA. The impact of land preparation and earthwork can be assessed using generic data accounting for the impact of the fuel consumption of construction machinery (e.g. skid-steer loaders or bulldozers).

This aspect can be neglected for most construction projects, as it is of minor relevance.

A-10 Product storage on site before installation – complete LCA

Aspect A-10 Product storage on site before installation – complete LCA

Description
Storage of products on arrival at site before installation includes such aspects as maintaining specific temperature or humidity in a storage space on site, and protection from weather, vandalism, theft, etc. Under the specific goal and scope this aspect might be interesting for, say, a construction company that needs to identify the hotspots of its construction site. Should the storage of products be considered in the context of a complete LCA?
Related
study objective
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Related
study phase
☒
goal and scope definition
☐
inventory analysis (LCI)
☐
impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
interpretation
☐
reporting
Relevant for
new buildings

existing buildings

building products

screening LCA

simplified LCA

complete LCA

Provisions
Product storage on site before installation should be included in complete LCA if it is relevant for the goal and scope of the study (e.g. a construction company might have more interest than a building designer on this aspect). If there are impacts from product storage (e.g. maintaining specific temperature or humidity conditions in a storage space on site) then this may be included in Module A5 next to the infrastructures required for the product storage (e.g. protection from weather, vandalism, theft), but these can be evaluated for significance using the cut-off rules. Any wastage because of poor product storage should be accounted for in Module A5 (manufacture, transport and disposal of wasted material).

Rules from
EN 15978
  • 8.5 Scenarios for the construction process stage (Modules A4-A5)

Guidance
The practitioner should use detailed calculation based on LCI data for complete LCA. For most construction projects, this aspect is likely to fall under cut-off rules.

A-12 Transport of construction workers – complete LCA

Aspect A-12 Transport of construction workers – complete LCA

Description
This aspect concerns the transportation of construction workers from home to work and to the construction site. Under specific goal and scope, this aspect might be interesting for, say, a construction company that needs to identify the hotspots of its construction site.
Related
study objective
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Related
study phase
☒
goal and scope definition
☐
inventory analysis (LCI)
☐
impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
interpretation
☐
reporting
Relevant for
new buildings

existing buildings

building products

screening LCA

simplified LCA

complete LCA

Provisions
The transport of construction workers may be included in complete LCA if it is relevant for the goal and scope of the study (e.g. a construction company might have more interest than a building designer in this aspect). In the context of a complete LCA, the transportation of workers to site may be taken into account based on detailed calculations if relevant for the goal and scope of the study, unless this aspect falls under cut-off rules.

Rules from
EN 15978
  • 8.5 Scenarios for the construction process stage (Modules A4–A5)

Guidance
The practitioner should use detailed calculation based on specific data for complete LCA. For more information about the relative share of impacts of the transport of workers, the practitioner can refer to the existing literature.

This aspect may be neglected for most building LCA studies, because it may fall outside the goal and scope. However, specific building stakeholders, such as construction companies, may have a special interest and thus will take it into account.

If taken into account, this aspect is likely to fall under cut-off rules for most construction projects. Unless the energy used for transport of staff to site is likely to exceed 1% of the primary energy requirement for the site operation, it is not necessary to collect data from staff on their journey to and from the construction site. If necessary, the significance could be reviewed by considering costs as a proxy for primary energy, although it should be recognized that petrol and diesel are often highly taxed relative to electricity. Such a statement should be supported through detailed studies of the construction stage. It will be revised if more evidence is available.

A-14 Transport of construction machinery to the building site – complete LCA

Aspect A-14 Transport of construction machinery to the building site – complete LCA

Description
This aspect concerns the transportation of machinery necessary for the construction of a building from the storage place to the construction site. Under specific goal and scope, this aspect might be interesting, e.g. for a construction company that needs to identify the hotspots of its construction site.
Related
study objective
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Related
study phase
☒
goal and scope definition
☐
inventory analysis (LCI)
☐
impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
interpretation
☐
reporting
Relevant for
new buildings

existing buildings

building products

screening LCA

simplified LCA

complete LCA

Provisions
In the context of a complete LCA, the transportation of construction machinery to site should be taken into account if it is relevant for the goal and scope of the study (e.g. a construction company might have more interest than a building designer on this aspect). Rules for estimation should follow the recommendations of EN 15804. In this case, practitioners should refer to the cut-off rules, and use detailed calculations for the transportation distances and load factors (unless this aspect falls under cut-off rules).

Rules from
EN 15978
  • 8.5 Scenarios for the construction process stage (Modules A4–A5)

Guidance
The practitioner should use specific data for the ancillary materials and for the processes or construction tools (which can be defined with stakeholders) for complete LCA. This aspect may be neglected for most construction projects, owing to its minor relevance.

A-16 Installation of the product into the building – complete LCA

Aspect A-16 Installation of the product into the building – complete LCA

Description
The installation of products into the building needs ancillary materials and processes (e.g. energy). What should be taken into account during the installation stage (e.g. drills, screwdrivers)?
Related
study objective
☒ stand-alone LCA ☒ comparative assertion
Related
study phase
☒
goal and scope definition
☐
inventory analysis (LCI)
☐
impact assessment (LCIA)
☐
interpretation
☐
reporting
Relevant for
new buildings

existing buildings

building products

screening LCA

simplified LCA

complete LCA

Provisions
The inclusion of ancillary materials should follow EN 15804/EN 15978. The energy and related emissions from the construction tools and installation of ancillary materials should follow EN 15978. They should be included for complete LCA studies, and particularly for cradle-to-grave product LCA.

Rules from
EN 15978
  • 8.5 Scenarios for the construction process stage (Modules A4–A5)
EN 15804
  • 6.2.3. A4–A5, Construction process stage, information modules
  • 7.3.2. Construction process stage

Guidance
General guidance for product LCA studies (e.g. EPD)

According to both EN 15804 and EN 15978, the installation of products into the building, including ancillary materials and their related processes, should be taken into account. The practitioner should comply with EN 15804 as far as possible, assuming the provisions are sufficiently clear. If an aspect is not clearly defined in the standard (e.g. there is so far no list of ancillary materials for the different applications of building products), the practitioner should always document assumptions made concerning the inclusion of ancillary materials.

Specific guidance for product LCA studies (e.g. EPD)

For cradle-to-grave product LCA, the practitioner needs to combine a cradle-to-gate LCA with some LCA data for ancillary materials implemented in the construction stage in order to fulfil the functional unit. For example, for cradle-to-grave EPD of a glued laminated timber beam in a building, the functional unit can be as follows: the function ‘support the structural elements from the roof for 100 years’ is defined for 1 ml of a beam of 5 m for a cross-section of 0.3 × 0.1 m. The ancillary materials in this case might be galvanized steel bolts, for example. The impacts related to their manufacture and transport to the site should be allocated to Module A5, as they are not primary raw materials in the wooden beam manufacturing process.

However, in other cases, e.g. ready-mixed concrete assembled on site with reinforcing steel, as these two raw materials are not ancillary materials the impacts of their manufacture and transport to the site should be allocated to Modules A3 and A4 respectively.

For other specific cases it may be tricky. For example, for ceramic tiles that need on-site mortar to be installed in the building, the allocation of the impacts of the mortar may be not clear, as it depends on the status of the mortar: is it a raw material next to the ceramic tiles (impact allocated to Modules A1–A3) or only an ancillary product (impact allocated only to Module A5)?

The more the environmental impacts of ancillary materials (related to manufacturing and transport to the site) are allocated to Module A5, the more relative impact this life cycle stage will have compared with production and end-of-life. It should be emphasized that the ancillary materials’ upstream impacts are not direct impact of a construction site.

In this context, the results for Module A5 should be interpreted accordingly.

Specific guidance for building LCA studies

For complete LCA the practitioner should use specific data for the ancillary materials, and for the processes or construction tools (which can be defined with stakeholders). For most construction projects, this aspect is likely to fall under cut-off rules.